The Linchpin

Note: This article is based in part on an episode in Castle and the rest on Seth Godin’s book called “Linchpin”, so read carefully and assess for yourself from which angle you wish to look at it.

The Butterfly Effect is this extremely curious scientific theory that tells us that the flapping of a butterfly’s wings in some location could lead to the formation of a tornado far, far away due a series of occurrences that are too long and slightly far-fetched to elaborate upon. However, this theory is the one that gives credence to the concept of a linchpin, the single most important event that if executed could alter all of history. Some instances reflecting the same:

  • the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, in Sarajevo on 28 June 1914 leading to the beginning of World War 1
  • The fact that Ken Lay was a Christian was the cause of the Enron collapse(explained here:
  • The setting up of the extremely kind and generous pension plan in Greece(done in the hopes of keeping the populace happy-a very valid reason) was the source of the economic collapse that we now see headlining international news

As we see, practically no one could have predicted the catastrophic events that proceeded such small acts(okay the assassination wasn’t small, but relative to a world war with millions of casualties it definitely was), but thanks to them we realise that the smallest of alterations can lead to a huge blip on the time scale that is our lives.Now, how does that matter?

Well consider this: Over 2 billion people live in poverty all over the world, and it might be possible, if we split them into separate demographics in an appropriate manner, to find the linchpin to completely change their fortunes. Why not? The situation is the same, except that the consequences of initiating the butterfly/linchpin effect are only positive. 

Then we consider global warming, could it be that destroying one specific company could lead to the avalanche reduction of global emissions? Who knows? How do we predict it? 

THAT is the crucial problem in this theory, we cannot in any satisfactory way show that there is this ONE specific event is the one that sets the ball rolling. Statistical/Probabilistic models can only hold so much weight at the end of the day, mainly because being the humans that we are, we’re sure to miss out some crucial factor that we did not foresee. Somehow I am clearly reminded of the concept of psycho-history that Isaac Asimov designed in his books; the concept of predicting the future based on mass decisions now. It fits into the very pattern we are speaking of right now! So maybe as we develop the models in tandem with the development of computers, we will eventually have the ability to compile all the factors and provide a legitimate way to predict the future. Anything is possible… Or is it really?


4 thoughts on “The Linchpin

  1. take this case of probability
    There is a 15 sided die, just imagine
    the mathematical probability of getting lets say 2 ,is obviously 1 in every 15 throws
    But when you roll the die 15 time does it actually come exactly once in every throw?
    It is “probably” doesnt.
    Will it come in lets say 2 in 30 throws, or exactly 5 in 75 throws ?
    How many throws do you think you can do to get a perfect multiple of 1 by 15
    Now apply this to the whole world which is way more complicated with more than just a factor of probability and WAAAAY more than 15 sides to get a perfect desired option
    Even considering that you dont want an exact number will make it too difficult
    I do not argue with your theory and it is nice but practical use in not far fetched it involves a factor called luck which isn probability
    A mystical force it is
    And every thing is possible ,not probable,
    I guess you already knew that
    Check out my blog

    • Hmm. See it’s something I used to believe but I’ve since changed my opinion, I do believe now that it’s possible for someone to caus one event to occur that alters an entire timeline, look at the examples they’re pretty clear in themselves. And as for the probability that you’ve considered, look at it like this, we may not be able to predict it perfectly, but the very fact that we can’t give rise to the existence of this possibility in itself since, suppose, all 15 throws of yours may actually be ‘2’s, and THAT is the situation that a “linchpin” is representative of.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s